Page 1 of 1

Which Probiotic/Prebiotic to start with

Posted: 05 Aug 2022, 13:37
by jleach04
There seems to be a ton of information on pro/pre biotics helping SIDs but I am at a loss as to which one to try first. Prior to his dx, we did use fortiflora for a time, which seemed to have some positive impact on his digestion. I am wondering if we should start with that one or wondering if there is a better one to try first. Looking to see what seems to have had the best results for folks. I know each EPI dog is different so if no hard feelings if any suggestions don't pan out. However, if I can give him the highest chance of success the first time around that is what we will try first.

Bruce is 6yr German Shepherd/Malinois, recently diagnosed EPI (also has IMHA). Currently on RC HP (mostly hard, but some canned) food, Enzyme Diane 6x powder 1 teaspoon per cup of food, takes IMHA meds with raw pumpkin (2 tablespoons per day). Currently he has normal poops (First time in 8 months) but seems to still have an upset stomach and tummy rumbles. He is eating but only about 80% of what he should be eating for a dog his size. I think the upset stomach is hindering his progress currently. He is currently 83 lbs and his goal weight is between 85-90 lbs so he is right on target but I dont want to lose ground if he is not eating enough. I am ordering some slippery elm but thought I would also order some pre/probiotics.

Also as an update to my previous post about his swollen lip, the benedryl seems to be working well and the swelling is down significantly, our next step is to figure out what is causing his allergy. The benedryl might be impacting his eating but that was an issue prior to the swollen lip so I think it will still be an issue once he is through his allergy flare-up.

Re: Which Probiotic/Prebiotic to start with

Posted: 06 Aug 2022, 13:15
by Johnnycake
I have tried many different options and have actually had the most success with a powdered colostrum supplement! I don't know how well this might work for others, but it has made a noticeable difference for Johnny and we've actually been able to cut back on some of the other stuff we were using, and no longer supplement with other probiotics.

We mix it in the same as we do the enzymes, it seems very palatable to him and there are lots of other beneficial nutrients, too! The particular one we use is from Manna Pro and we get it from the same tractor/farm supply store that we get the needles for his B12 injections.

Re: Which Probiotic/Prebiotic to start with

Posted: 06 Aug 2022, 22:23
by Jane&Clyde
Slippery elm works as a prebiotic, so there is no need to add an additional one if you are using it. Three of the probiotics that are recommended here are Dr. Mercola Complete, Visbiome, and Proviable. Whatever probiotic you use, be sure to start with less than half of the recommended dose, then slowly work your way up until you get to the recommended dose or find a level that works for your dog.

Personally, my dog did best on the Dr. Mercola Complete, followed by Visbiome, then the Proviable. However, I know that many dogs do great on Proviable. The Dr. Mercola Complete and the Visbiome will look astronomically expensive at first glance. However, Clyde was able to get good results from 1/4 to 1/3 of the suggested maintenance dose of both of those which makes them less expensive than it initially looks like.

Re: Which Probiotic/Prebiotic to start with

Posted: 02 Jun 2023, 20:04
by Jaqueline
Johnnycake wrote: 06 Aug 2022, 13:15 I have tried many different options and have actually had the most success with a powdered colostrum supplement! I don't know how well this might work for others, but it has made a noticeable difference for Johnny and we've actually been able to cut back on some of the other stuff we were using, and no longer supplement with other probiotics.
We mix it in the same as we do the enzymes, it seems very palatable to him and there are lots of other beneficial nutrients, too! The particular one we use is from Manna Pro and we get it from the same tractor/farm supply store that we get the needles for his B12 injections.
oh the same. I'll try.

Re: Which Probiotic/Prebiotic to start with

Posted: 02 Jun 2023, 21:12
by Jaqueline
Jaqueline wrote: 02 Jun 2023, 20:04
Johnnycake wrote: 06 Aug 2022, 13:15 I have tried many different options and have actually had the most success with a powdered colostrum supplement! I don't know how well this might work for others, but it has made a noticeable difference for Johnny and we've actually been able to cut back on some of the other stuff we were using, and no longer supplement with other probiotics.
We mix it in the same as we do the enzymes, it seems very palatable to him and there are lots of other beneficial nutrients, too! The particular one we use is from Manna Pro and we get it from the same tractor/farm supply store that we get the needles for his B12 injections.https://trapthecat3.com
oh the same. I'll try.
But it's not success.

Re: Which Probiotic/Prebiotic to start with

Posted: 02 Jun 2023, 21:17
by Montgomery
Journal everything your pup eats and don't let him run free-range for a bit. There are so many things this time of year that can cause allergic reactions. My neighbour's cat La Bamba had yanked all the hair from the backs of her ears. She is allergic to the hedge, it turns out.

Re: Which Probiotic/Prebiotic to start with

Posted: 03 Jun 2023, 01:32
by Chance
The pre/probiotic can be a loaded question. As you mentioned, every dog is different. I think it can depend on the severity of the dysbiosis.

I tried 5 different products before stumbling on one that appeared to help. Finally #5 is what showed merit! Each time we had a SIBO setback, I took it to mean that the probiotic I was giving wasn't the answer. Probiotic #2 (sold by the vet - Aventi GI - was the only one that seemed to make matters worse. Causing discomfort in the tummy). Probiotic #4 was Proviable. This is one that us quite common in the EPI community. But it just wasn't strong enough for my dog. It's a decent one, but at 7 billion CFU, it's very, very weak.

Probiotic #5 was Garden of Life, Restore. This one has 100 billion CFU per capsule, so very high potency! (The bottle is misleading. It says 200 billion; but that's for 2 capsules). Due to the strength of this one, I started very slowly, gradually building up. Started at about 1/4 capsule per day. I did that for 4 days, then 1/2 capsule for 4 days before going to a full capsule per day.

Visbiome is another one that is very high potency. I have recently bought this one (as it has pretty much the same strains). I do believe this one is also very good! According to Visbiome, the pet version is exactly the same as the human version. (This is one you'd also build up gradually).

Re: Which Probiotic/Prebiotic to start with

Posted: 22 Dec 2023, 19:04
by Montgomery
How? Someone correct me if I'm wrong here, but someone with EPI has to have enzymes with each meal, and thus, everything they eat is controlled. Montgomery lives with eight other cats who all eat different things, but I know everything that he's intested, how much, and when.

Re: Which Probiotic/Prebiotic to start with

Posted: 28 Dec 2023, 22:35
by jessefay
Keep a food journal for your dog and restrict him freedom of movement for a while. This time of year, a lot of things might trigger allergic responses. pico park